According to my What's Your Favorite Valentine's Day Candy? poll, chocolate--in the aggregate--rated highest. Of course, there's no surprise there. The seasonal shapes, colors, and candies rated highly as well. (Full disclosure time: I heart cinnamon hearts.)
I'm going to come up with a Valentine's Day cookie that incorporates all the best-loved flavors, shapes, and colors of the season. So stay tuned!
Thanks to all who voted and commented. (Alicia: Next time I'll include a button for "all of the above." I promise!) Voting still remains open, so feel free to weigh in.