According to my Easter Treats poll, chocolate (surprise, surprise) was readers' top choice for Easter candy. In fact, chocolate took out Peeps, the next highest rated pick, by a margin of well over 2-1.
I voted for jelly beans, but they might be a little hard to incorporate into a cookie. They'd probably just melt into lumps of goo. But that might be a good thing, especially if I use them to make stained glass cookies. Hmm...I'll have to think about that.
Thanks to all who voted and commented. You've given me some great ideas! Voting still remains open, so feel free to weigh in.