My Photo

Feed Me


« 'Tis the Season for Pumpkin & Chocolate Chip Cookies II | Main | Picturing Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookies »

November 04, 2008


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


These sound SO-O-O yummy!! Please put them on the menu for Thanksgiving. Looking forward to piggin' out on these babies!!

Tracey in WA

YUMMY!!! I will have to try these for sure!!! Did you get my e-mqail I sent you?

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

You betcha, Mumma!

Thanks, Tracey. Yup...I got your Halloween email. Did you carve those pumpkins yourself? :-)

Princess Ariele

Thank you Greg! These are truly amazing...I think your best yet.

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Thanks, Princess Ariele! I'm so glad you liked them. :-)


Doggone it! Me and my big mouth. I have the nerve to give you another idea for a cookie and am not in NYC to taste them. RATS!!!! Mumma will have to tell me how they are after Thanksgiving. Tell her I'm counting on her.


Ok I am so excited to have found your blog! I love to bake-especially cookies and all your recipes look amazing! I can't wait to get started making all your recipes, I cant decide where to start!

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Alicia. Thanks for the flavor suggestion! I'll have Mumma comment on them. :-)

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Brooke. Thanks so much! Let me know how the cookies come out. I love the feedback. :-)


Okay, so I'm making these for Thanksgiving this year, looking over what ingredients I need, and...

Under "Filling" it says "2 1/2 Pumpkin Pie Spice". I'm going to assume that's teaspoons? I'll just run with that...

I'll let you know how fast they disappear, thanks for all the great cookie recipes!!

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Nancy. Oops! Thanks for pointing that out! I've updated the recipe to say "teaspoons." I can't wait to hear how they come out!


I have been wanting to try your recipes for a while. And today I finally made some of these. Instead of using pumpkin pie filling, I used fresh pumpkin. I don't know how big of a difference it made, but the cookies taste delicious.

This might be a silly question....but I should refrigerate the cookies right? (since there is cheesecake....?)

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Jennifer. Yay! I'm so glad you made these and that you liked them. Swapping out the pumpkin pie filling with fresh pumpkin was a neat idea. You probably should refrigerate them. I usually don't have many left over when I make my cheesecake-stuffed cookies, so refrigeration hasn't been an issue. But if you've got leftovers, just go ahead and pop them in the fridge. Thanks for writing in! :-)


I made these today and they were yummy! However, because our spice cabinet is actually just a whole bunch of little plastic baggies with worn off sharpie, I accidentally used garam masala instead of the pie spice. It still tasted pretty good to me, though! Maybe just a little spicier. Thanks for such a great recipe!

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Melissa. Ha! Now *that's* a happy accident! I'm so glad you liked the cookies, even with the slight spice adjustment. :-)

Wendy Taber

These cookies sound wonderful...and I would love to make them to send to my nephew who is a Marine serving in Okinawa right now. His favorite dessert in pumpkin cheesecake. Packages take about 5 days to get there. Do you think they will last that long? Or not a good idea? Thanks Wendy

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Wendy. Unfortunately, it's probably not a good idea to ship these guys over a long distance. I've done some research on the safety of cream cheese. Check this out:


nice!!!! this is next week's baking project! brought in some french toast & bacon cupcakes for the office today- huge hit, but no one can say no to a cream cheese filled cookie!

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Bird. Those cupcakes sound AWESOME!!!!


I'm a HUGE fan of pumpkin cheescake and made these last night. They are AMAZING! I never would have thought to bake with graham crackers!

Oatmeal Cookie Guy

Hi, Olivia. Thanks! So glad you liked these. :-)

Alina Charis Parrott

What do you think about dipping half in chocolate and giving as gifts? I think I'm going to try the cookie first. I will be making them today. Along with Chocolate Turtles, Caramel Chocolate Apples, and Chocolate covered candy canes for gifts.

The comments to this entry are closed.